Yeah, while it's always good to get the case out there for people to hear but she definitely had a few facts wrong. She said Josh and Katie broke up a month before his disappearance and it was actually several months. She said he had 7-12 beers while at the party. He was only there less than an hour so we know that isn't true. I believe authorities said they estimated this total was over the course of the evening. She also said Erika Dahlquist was kidnapped from Minneapolis, but it was actually Brainerd (which is a fair distance north of Minneapolis). And this is a common mistake made by podcasters and the like, that Josh missed a mock trial on that Sunday. He just missed a financial/budget meeting regarding the mock trial team. She also says that Josh was catfishing men on the internet. This is a little slippery as I don't believe anyone can definitively say that is a fact. And for her to say either Nick or Katie is "lying" about the timeline after he left her campus apartment is kind of dramatic. I believe their timelines are a little different but I don't know if we can jump to conclusions that one of them is lying. And then to speculate if Nick went to the abbey in that time is a bit ridiculous to me. You're just feeding into the Unsolved Mysteries hype about Nick. Let's hope we get some real news on the case soon. Happy holidays, everyone

I always wondering did Nick take the Link bus home (that runs between the universities) or did he drive home? The bus only runs a few times after midnight before shutting down for the night. Also, the dorms had curfews on when your guests needed to leave. Not saying people didn't break them, but how do those timelines line up with Nick's story.

I just thought about this again, too. I thought Josh's case had the chance to have a similar breakthrough as with the Carey Mae Parker case, which first opened my eyes to the potential of podcasts to make a difference. I guess it was not to be.